Why I Think the Next Wonder Woman Should Come Down to Eiza González and Andra Anjua

Wonder Woman: A Legacy Bigger Than One Actress

Since 1941, Wonder Woman has stood as more than just another superhero — she’s been a symbol of power, compassion, and hope. Gal Gadot’s portrayal, especially in Patty Jenkins’ 2017 film, elevated Diana Prince into a modern icon, blending fierce physicality with a genuine vulnerability that resonated across the globe. Gadot proved that Wonder Woman could be both a fearsome warrior and a beacon of humanity. Now, with James Gunn and Peter Safran crafting a new era for DC, the next casting isn’t simply about who fits the costume — it’s about who can carry forward a legacy. Whoever steps into Diana’s boots has to balance mythic grandeur with emotional depth, and convince audiences that Wonder Woman’s story still matters in a rapidly shifting superhero landscape.

Eiza González: Star Power and Proven Action Chops

When it comes to sheer Hollywood credentials, Eiza González is impossible to ignore. Her career has been a steady climb through blockbuster territory, from Baby Driver to Godzilla vs. Kong and Michael Bay’s Ambulance. She has the height, presence, and kinetic energy to look completely at home on the battlefields of Themyscira, sword in hand and tiara glinting in the sun. Eiza’s bilingual background also brings potential for wider global reach, a factor studios increasingly care about as international markets drive box office profits. However, there’s a lingering question: while Eiza excels in explosive action, has she truly shown the layers of emotional complexity that defined Gal Gadot’s Wonder Woman? Gadot’s Diana wasn’t just a fighter; she was a character grappling with centuries of loss, love, and the burden of divine heritage. Eiza feels like a safe and potentially seamless transition — the kind of casting that signals stability for the franchise without necessarily reinventing it. But safe choices can sometimes lack the spark of surprise that makes an icon unforgettable.

Andra Anjua: The Unknown Who Could Rewrite the Script

Then there’s Andra Anjua — the wildcard. Andra isn’t yet a household name, but that’s precisely why she intrigues me. When Gal Gadot was first announced, many doubted whether an actress best known for the Fast & Furious franchise could handle a role as nuanced as Diana Prince. Yet that blank-slate casting turned out to be a stroke of genius, allowing Gadot to define Wonder Woman on her own terms. Andra could offer the same opportunity. Industry chatter suggests she’s delivered compelling performances in indie films, hinting at an ability to capture both Wonder Woman’s regal strength and her quiet vulnerabilities. Casting her would signal that DC is serious about a fresh creative direction — a Wonder Woman who might feel more contemporary, perhaps a little rawer and more relatable. The risk is clear: a billion-dollar franchise on the shoulders of a relative newcomer is a roll of the dice. But if DC truly wants to shake off the ghosts of its past and build a new mythology, Andra Anjua might be the bold choice who makes audiences sit up and pay attention.

The Verdict

Fans are already choosing sides. Eiza González offers star power and proven action credentials — the kind of casting that would keep the franchise’s momentum steady and give audiences a familiar face to rally behind. Andra Anjua, on the other hand, represents possibility: the chance to reshape Wonder Woman from the ground up and deliver a Diana Prince who surprises us all. Both women bring different strengths to the table, and both deserve to be at the center of this conversation.

Because here’s the truth: the next Wonder Woman can’t simply be a warrior in armor. She has to be an icon audiences believe in — a hero whose battles feel personal as well as epic. Whether DC plays it safe or takes a bold leap, the decision they make now will ripple through the franchise for the next decade.

And that’s why, in my book, it should come down to Eiza González and Andra Anjua.

Who’s your pick for the next Wonder Woman — the Hollywood star or the hidden gem? Let’s argue @thetipsycriticreview for daily updates on your favorite shows, movies, and all the drama in between!

🎟️ Wanna catch up on Wonder Woman’s past adventures?
From Gal Gadot’s iconic turn to the larger DC universe, you can binge all the action—and loads more—for FREE for 30 days with Amazon Prime Video. Cancel anytime.

👉 Start your Amazon Prime Video free trial here