Edi Gathegi Says Mr. Terrific Is His Payback After X-Men Promise Went Up in Smoke

If there’s one actor proving Hollywood karma is real, it’s Edi Gathegi. Because after Marvel left him for dead in X-Men: First Class, he’s getting the last laugh — and a ton of praise — as Mr. Terrific in James Gunn’s Supermanreboot.

“I was told Darwin would definitely come back,” Gathegi told The Hollywood Reporter. “That didn’t happen. Now, with Mr. Terrific… I actually get to save the world.”

It’s the kind of superhero glow-up fans love — and Gathegi’s finally getting the screen time he deserves.

From Marvel’s Darwin Disaster to DC’s New Genius Hero

Rewind to 2011, when Edi Gathegi first entered the superhero world as Armando Muñoz, a.k.a. Darwin, in X-Men: First Class. Darwin’s mutant power is literally to “adapt to survive anything.” Fire? He grows fireproof skin. Underwater? He grows gills.

So fans were furious when Darwin was killed off halfway through the film by Sebastian Shaw (Kevin Bacon) — an explosion he somehow couldn’t adapt to survive.

“It didn’t make sense for Darwin to die,” Gathegi admitted. “The whole point of his power is that he can’t die. But I trusted the studio when they told me, ‘Don’t worry, we’re bringing him back.’”

But those promises went up in smoke. Gathegi never returned, and Darwin became one of the biggest “what could’ve been” tragedies in Marvel movie history.

Enter Mr. Terrific — Edi Gathegi’s Superhero Redemption

Fast forward to 2025. Gathegi lands a major role in the new DC Universe as Michael Holt, aka Mr. Terrific — a character known in the comics as the “third smartest man in the world.”

Mr. Terrific isn’t just tech support for Superman. In Gunn’s Superman (2025), he’s:

✅ A brilliant strategist.
✅ A badass inventor rocking floating “T-Spheres.”
✅ A voice of reason in Superman’s political firestorm.
✅ And — crucially — alive and kicking by the end credits.

“Mr. Terrific lets me actually do something heroic,” Gathegi told GamesRadar. “I’m not just there to die early so the stakes feel higher.”

This is the kind of redemption arc superhero fans crave. Gathegi finally gets to flex both his dramatic chops and his comedic timing — and it’s turning heads.

A Potential Spin-Off on the Horizon?

Rumors are already swirling that James Gunn and DC Studios are considering spin-offs for characters introduced in Superman — and Gathegi’s name keeps popping up.

“We’re exploring how characters like Mr. Terrific could fit into their own stories,” Gunn teased in a recent Q&A. “Fans are clearly responding to him.”

Industry insiders report that Gathegi’s performance “steals every scene he’s in,” with fans praising his cool confidence and brainy charm.

Some have called Gathegi’s Mr. Terrific “the MVP of the new DCU,” a title he’s more than earned after what went down at Fox.

Fans React: Justice Served or Studio Hype?

Across Reddit, Twitter, and TikTok, fans can’t stop talking about Gathegi’s career turnaround:

• “Marvel wasted Darwin. DC’s making him Terrific.”

• “Justice for Darwin finally came… just in another universe.”

• “Edi Gathegi deserves his own series. Period.”

But some fans remain cautious. They’ve seen superhero franchises hype supporting characters before — only to drop them when box office numbers fall short.

Still, the buzz around Gathegi’s performance is overwhelmingly positive. Many fans feel like Hollywood finally “did right by him.”

The Final Word

Edi Gathegi’s path from Marvel’s forgotten hero to DC’s brainiest star is the stuff of Hollywood legend. After getting short-changed as Darwin, he’s now:

✨ Stealing scenes in Superman.
✨ Earning praise from critics and fans alike.
✨ Possibly heading for his own DCU spotlight.

“Mr. Terrific is my full-circle moment,” Gathegi said. “I finally get to be a hero who matters.”

Whether Mr. Terrific gets his own solo project remains to be seen. But one thing’s certain: Edi Gathegi is no longer just the guy who died in X-Men. He’s a legit superhero — and he’s here to stay.

➡️ For more superhero news, movie chaos, and unapologetic takes, follow @thetipsycriticreview on Instagram!