Dakota Johnson Says ‘Madame Web’ Flop ‘Wasn’t My Fault’: Hollywood Decisions Made by “People Who Don’t Have a Creative Bone in Their Body”

When Dakota Johnson recently addressed the failure of Madame Web at the box office, she didn’t mince words. The Sony-backed superhero film, which was expected to be a major hit in early 2024, instead bombed critically and commercially — earning only $43 million domestically and a shocking 11% on Rotten Tomatoes. But according to Johnson, the blame lies far beyond her performance or commitment to the role.

During her press tour for the upcoming indie drama Materialists, Johnson candidly explained that Hollywood’s creative decision-making process is often fragmented, muddled, and dominated by executives who lack a true artistic vision. This is a phenomenon that, she says, ultimately doomed Madame Web before it even had a chance to succeed.

“There’s this thing that happens now where a lot of creative decisions are made by committee. Or made by people who don’t have a creative bone in their body. And it’s really hard to make art that way. Or to make something entertaining that way,” Johnson told the Los Angeles Times.

The Rise and Fall of Madame Web

Madame Web arrived with high hopes as part of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe, a franchise aiming to build its own superhero legacy separate from Marvel Studios. Dakota Johnson’s casting as Cassandra Webb, a paramedic who gains precognitive powers after a near-death experience, was seen as an inspired choice, combining her dramatic chops with blockbuster appeal.

Yet from the outset, signs of trouble emerged. The film’s marketing campaign struggled to find a clear identity, and critics pointed to a confusing plot and uneven tone. Early test screenings reportedly caused concern, but instead of course-correcting, the film underwent a series of re-edits and last-minute changes — a common fate for large studio productions controlled by multiple stakeholders.

The results were clear: Madame Web left audiences puzzled and critics unimpressed. With an 11% Rotten Tomatoes score, it became one of the most reviled comic book adaptations of recent years.

Dakota Johnson’s Perspective: “It Wasn’t My Fault”

What sets Johnson apart from many actors caught in a box office failure is her refusal to accept sole blame. In her interview, she emphasized that big-budget movies fail all the time — often due to factors beyond the actors’ control.

“I was just sort of along for the ride at that point. But that happens,” Johnson said.

She described how the film’s original vision was compromised by layers of executive input, rewrites, and studio mandates. This creative dilution made it nearly impossible for the cast and filmmakers to deliver a cohesive, heartfelt story.

Johnson also shared her frustration with how Hollywood prioritizes algorithms and numbers over artistic integrity and genuine audience connection:

“You cannot make art based on numbers and algorithms. My feeling has been for a long time that audiences are extremely smart, and executives have started to believe that they’re not. Audiences will always be able to sniff out bullshit.”

This sentiment hits at the core of why Madame Web struggled — the film felt manufactured, inauthentic, and disconnected from what comic book fans and moviegoers actually wanted.

Hollywood’s Committee Culture and Its Impact

Johnson’s remarks highlight a larger industry issue: the “committee culture” in Hollywood where many decisions are subject to layers of approval, test screenings, and focus groups. While designed to minimize risk, this approach often stifles creativity and leaves films feeling watered down or confused.

The pressure to appeal to a broad demographic can lead studios to lose sight of the story’s soul. This was particularly apparent with Madame Web, where attempts to balance superhero spectacle, mystery, and character drama never fully gelled.

For Dakota Johnson, this environment is frustrating but not unfamiliar. She’s been vocal about the difficulty of finding roles that truly resonate, especially within the romantic comedy genre, where she feels many scripts lack “soul and heart.” The same can be said of Madame Web’s production, which began with promise but lost its way amid creative compromises.

What Could Madame Web Have Done Differently?

Industry insiders suggest several reasons why Madame Web didn’t land:

• Unclear tone and story direction: The film juggled multiple genres without a unified voice.

• Studio interference: Last-minute reshoots and edits diluted the director’s vision.

• Poor marketing: The campaign failed to clearly communicate what the film was about or why audiences should care.

• Audience fatigue: The superhero genre has become saturated, and audiences are selective about what they invest in.

Johnson’s own experience is a reminder that even talented actors and crews can’t always overcome systemic issues in production and studio management.

Looking Ahead: Dakota Johnson’s Career and Materialists

Despite Madame Web’s flop, Dakota Johnson is not deterred. She’s now focusing on Materialists, an indie film praised for its complex characters and authentic storytelling. This project is a fresh start and a return to the kind of nuanced roles Johnson values.

She told Bustle last year that she’s picky about scripts because many lack genuine heart, and she’s excited that Materialists delivers on emotional truth — something that was missing in Madame Web’s development process.

Conclusion: The Real Lessons from Madame Web

The failure of Madame Web is not just a story about one movie but a cautionary tale about Hollywood’s current creative pitfalls. When films are shaped by committees and executives with little creative vision, even talented actors like Dakota Johnson can’t save them.

Johnson’s honest comments remind us that art and entertainment need freedom to flourish. Audiences want stories that feel authentic and heartfelt — not products churned out by algorithmic decision-making.

As Dakota Johnson moves forward with more meaningful projects, the hope is that Hollywood will listen and give filmmakers and actors the space they need to create stories that truly connect.

Want More Real Hollywood Insights?

➡️ Follow @thetipsycriticreview on Instagram for exclusive interviews, behind-the-scenes stories, and honest takes on Hollywood’s biggest hits and misses.

➡️ Visit The Tipsy Critic for in-depth breakdowns of your favorite movies, from blockbusters to indie gems.

➡️ Join the conversation on our forum here and share your thoughts on Madame Web and Dakota Johnson’s future projects.